The results of our first Reader’s Choice Tele-Tuesday comedy polls are in. Last week, we asked our readers one simple question: if you could watch only one comedy per night, what would it be?
We’re watching more comedies than ever here at The Ooo Factor. While some of our favorite veteran comedies still air today, we may have a different favorite that has taken over on that particular night of the week, and we feel an obligation to update our readers with the 2012 choices.
Did the Tele-Tuesday readers agree with our picks? Find out today in A Pick Per Night 2012: The Comedies.
For us at The Ooo Factor, comedy on Sunday night means Showtime. And lately, our top choice is Californication.
Hank Moody (David Duchovny) has never met a drug or a woman that he doesn’t love. Pair that with his recurring writer’s block, and Hank’s life is a disaster just waiting to happen.
The show starts after Hank, and his baby’s momma, Karen (Natascha McElhone) move with their daughter, Becca (Madeleine Martin) from New York to Los Angeles. Joining the Moody clan, is Hanks’ agent/BFF, Charlie Runkle (Evan Handler), and his wife, Marcy (Pamela Adlon), a waxing professional to the stars.
Hank’s successful novel was adapted into a screenplay much to his dismay, and feeling down-n-out, he picks up a hot Mia (Madeline Zima) in a local LA bookstore and beds her. That is, after all, what Hank Moody does — he beds beautiful women with his alluring charm. During sex, Mia punches Hank in the face; not long after “the punch,” Hank discovers that Mia is the 16 year old daughter of Karen’s new fiancé. And, there we have the setting for all five seasons thus far.
Californication is pure brilliance, but raunchy. One of the most unforgettable scenes took place early in Season 1… let’s just say it involved Hank and Charlie in bed, with a “shooter.” Watch with caution…. but be prepared to laugh and cry! In Season 2, Hank is hired to write the biography of a rock star (Callum Keith Rennie) — just what Hank needs, an invitation to party like a rock star! In Season 3, Hank is hired as a college professor — that’s definitely a disaster waiting to happen! One of our favorite laugh-out-loud, tears-streaming-down-our-face scenes aired in Season 4 with the entire cast of characters sitting around Stu’s (Stephen Tobolowsky) dinner table. Season 5 just ended Sunday night with Hank and Karen hot on the mend of what could be “happily ever after” until one of Hank’s crazy exes shows up and drugs him – classic Californication cliffhanger!!
Reader’s Choice: Family Guy came in first with 30% of the reader’s vote, with The Simpsons following close behind with 26%. Is anyone else with us who can’t believe The Simpsons is still on air, airing new episodes? How many seasons is this? CRAZY!
Monday: 2 Broke Girls
First we have Max (Kat Dennings) — Manhattan nanny by day and Brooklyn diner waitress by night. Max has control of her life, a life that’s not extravagant by any means; she has her own apartment, boyfriend, and overall seems happy. That is until the diner hires a blonde, dressed like she owns the place, to share shifts with her.
Next we meet Caroline (Beth Behrs) — a former Manhattan socialite who has lost everything courtesy of her father’s Ponzi scheme. Caroline runs away from her life, not that she has a choice, and chooses Brooklyn as her new residence (because according to a Google search, Brooklyn is the least likely place anyone from her former circle visits).
Caroline doesn’t need or use her Ivy-league education and her business and marketing background to wait tables, until she discovers the diner is not selling the tasty cupcakes for enough money — Max’s cupcakes. Caroline knows that in the city, people will pay $7-$10 a cupcake, and she begins pocketing some extra cash and creates a business plan. Now, all she needs is Max to hop on board.
Although it’s very difficult for her to do, Max invites Caroline to stay with her. After a boyfriend mishap, the two bond and despite Max’s constant put-downs, the girls plan to start a new life together and open a cupcakery — Max is the talent and Caroline is the brains. We’ve seen both characters grow during the first half of season one, even if their cupcake funds haven’t (at the end of each episode, the cupcake savings tallies on the screen for the audience – the girls have a long way to go to reach $250,000).
We only set the pilot of 2 Broke Girls to record so we could say, “We checked it out.” After all, the sitcom is created by Michael Patrick King (Sex and the City) and comedian Whitney Cummings, and it fills a very popular time slot between CBS’ How I Met Your Mother and Two and a Half Men. But after only one episode, we returned to the series option on the DVR and updated the recording to grab all of the new episodes. Even the man of the house has watched a few episodes and laughs out loud, even if he won’t admit it.
Reader’s Choice: How I Met Your Mother came in first with 35% of the vote. We’re also big HIMYM fans here at Tele-Tuesday, but our previous Monday night favorite was bumped this year for multiple reasons.
#1 – Many of the 2011-2012 episodes have ended on a very sad note; we thought this was supposed to be a comedy?
#2 – Maybe, just maybe, the writers are dragging out the story of how Ted meets his kids’ mother a bit too long?
#3 – We laugh out-loud at 2 Broke Girls more than we do at HIMYM, including Barney’s classic ‘isms.
Tuesday: New Girl
New Girl stars Zooey Deschanel as Jess Day, a likeable young teacher piecing together her life after a breakup. Many words can be used to describe Jess: adorable, goofy, vulnerable, faithful, awkward, and offbeat — or as Fox advertises, adorakable.
She finds a “roommate wanted” situation via Craig’s List and moves in with three single men — the bartender Nick (Jake Johnson), the Casanova-like Schmidt (Max Greenfield), and the former European basketball star, Winston (Lamorne Morris). The men, and Jess’ best friend Cece (Hannah Simone) help teach Jess and themselves all about life, love, and the ever-important self.
The opening number of New Girl is the only introduction that literally has us bobbing our heads back and forth and singing along with it. That may not be a reason to watch a television show, but it surely doesn’t hurt. “Hey, girl! What’cha doin’?” … “Who’s that girl? Who’s that girl? It’s JESS!” Okay, so everyone probably needs to hear the music to enjoy along with us.
That said, every single one of the actors and actresses in New Girl has beautiful comedic timing. Zooey Deschanel tops the funny chart, with Jake Johnson (Nick) following close behind. But who steals the show? Max Greenfield (Schmidt).
Schmidt is a mess! Is he gay? No; he’s straight and he beds many beautiful women (including Jess’ best friend, Cece — but that’s a secret, for now). Just when viewers are convinced Schmidt is straight, he makes some other comment or action that leads us to believe he’s gay. Does it matter? Absolutely not! Is he believable in both roles? Yes! Do we love his “Schmidtisms”? Without a doubt!!
But most of all, New Girl portrays life as it is — not simple, not full of hand-outs, and always in motion. The friendships between the characters serves as the glue that holds everything together, but the character growth may be the “it” factor that keeps New Girl around for a long time…
Reader’s Choice: None came in first with 43% of the vote.
Yikes!! So if no one is watching a sitcom on Tuesday nights, may we recommend New Girl? Seriously. Where are our New Girl fans? Talk it up in the comments and maybe, just maybe, we can convert some viewers!
Developed, written, and starring comedian Whitney Cummings, Whitney follows the fictionalized story of her life experiences, challenges in relationships we can all relate to — like cohabitation, friendships, secrets, and boundaries. Whitney lives with her long-term boyfriend, Alex (Chris D’Elia), and the non-traditional couple sees no reason to get married, but remains happily ever after nonetheless.
The duo is surrounded by their friends: Lily (Zoe Lister-Jones), who believes in happily ever after, Roxanne (Rhea Seehorn), a relationship cynic, Neal (Maulik Pancholy) who appears to be in a perfect relationship with Lily but later decides he may actually like men instead, and Mark (Dan O’Brien), the self-proclaimed ultimate bachelor.
Each week, we laugh throughout the thirty minute series. Whitney is perfect viewing for couples to watch together. One of our favorite episodes is when Whitney walks in on Alex’s “alone” time (trying to keep the blog clean here…).
Needless to say, Alex was and is completely mortified, and Whitney begins knocking on her own apartment door to announce when she arrives home each time after the incident. The episode continues as Whitney confesses the day’s events to her friends, further embarrassing Alex.
Which brings us to the relatable part: what’s safe to share with outsiders, even those we love the most, when working through moments that take place between lovers and partners?
This sitcom might perhaps evoke more giggles in our house than our previous favorite (How I Met Your Mother), courtesy of the relatability and laugh factors for men and women alike.
Reader’s Choice: South Park came in first with 25% of the vote, with Modern Family at a close second with 21%.
First of all, this is shocking. While we do like South Park, we are floored that more people didn’t vote for Modern Family. We really, really thought it would be the show to beat.
Wednesday was the toughest of the days to choose from for us at Tele-Tuesday. While we obviously selected Whitney from our blurb above, Suburgatory starring Jeremy Sisto deserves a mention (it came in toward the bottom with only 7% of the vote). The relationship between George and Tess (father and daughter) is touching, but the real Ooo Factor love goes to screen-stealers Dallas (Cheryl Hines) and Noah (Alan Tudyk). Only 7% of the vote…. Where’s our Suburgatory fan club? Will someone join us in trying to convince our readers to check it out?
Not offended by South Park? Love to watch Family Guy? FX has introduced Archer – pure animation brilliance. Meet ISIS (International Secret Intelligence Service):
Sterling Archer — an alcoholic, sex crazed secret agent, who also happens to be a breast cancer survivor (Team Rampage!). Think James Bond meets Hank Moody…
Malory Archer — Archer’s alcoholic, nymphomaniac mother/boss, whose apparent affair with the leader of the KGB resulted in Archer’s birth (although we’re still awaiting confirmation). Think Miss Moneypenny…
Lana Kane — Archer’s sexy bombshell ex-girlfriend/partner who wants to be #1, and always wears her machine gun around her shoulder like a purse . Think Lara Croft…
Cheryl — ISIS’ billionaire secretary with an S&M fetish.
Pam — The Human Resource director and head-gossip, who is as sex crazed as the rest of the team.
Archer’s 30-minutes of raunchy humor are an absolute must see! I mentioned raunchy, right?
Archer is also the only one of the comedies that actually made our A Pick Per Night 2011 list. And here it is again, staying strong in 2012. Seems it has something going for it…
Reader’s Choice: The Big Bang Theory came in first with 63% of the total vote. This is the largest winning margin than any other show (comedy or drama). Now this, we expected…
Did your favorite comedy win? If not, what is it and tell us why it should have? For those that love New Girl and Suburgatory, share with us why others should check these two new sitcoms out! We’d love to hear from you!